Peer Review Process
Peer Review Policy
The Journal International Review of Research Studies – JIRRS adopts a double-anonymous peer review system as the standard procedure for evaluating research manuscripts submitted to the journal.
Under this model, the identities of the authors are not disclosed to the reviewers, and the identities of the reviewers remain anonymous to the authors throughout the evaluation process.
The peer review process is designed to ensure the scientific quality, methodological soundness, ethical integrity, originality, transparency and reliability of the works published by JIRRS.
Editorial decisions are based exclusively on scholarly merit, relevance to the journal’s scope, scientific quality, ethical compliance and contribution to knowledge. Publication fees, institutional affiliations, nationality, academic status, commercial interests or any other factor unrelated to scientific merit do not influence editorial decisions.
1. Scope of Peer Review
All scholarly manuscripts submitted to JIRRS and considered eligible for scientific evaluation are subject to peer review.
This includes, when applicable:
- original research articles;
- review articles;
- systematic reviews;
- methodological studies;
- case studies;
- applied research articles;
- technical or interdisciplinary research manuscripts;
- manuscripts submitted to regular issues;
- manuscripts submitted to special issues, thematic issues or special calls for papers.
Editorial materials, announcements, corrections, retractions, expressions of concern and other non-research content may be assessed internally by the editorial team, according to their nature and purpose.
2. Review Model
JIRRS uses a double-anonymous peer review system.
Authors do not receive the identities of reviewers. Reviewers do not receive the identities of authors during the evaluation process.
Authors must remove from the anonymised manuscript any information that may reveal authorship, including:
- author names;
- institutional affiliations;
- acknowledgements;
- author biographies;
- funding information that directly identifies the authors;
- institutional identifiers;
- self-identifying statements;
- file metadata or document properties that reveal authorship.
Author information, affiliations, funding statements, conflicts of interest and acknowledgements must be provided separately in the submission system or in the appropriate metadata fields, according to the journal’s instructions.
The editorial office may return a manuscript to the authors before review if anonymisation is incomplete.
3. Technical Check
After submission, the editorial office performs an initial technical check before editorial assessment.
At this stage, the following aspects may be verified:
- manuscript completeness;
- author information and metadata;
- correspondence between the manuscript and the journal’s scope;
- anonymisation of the manuscript;
- structure and formatting;
- presence of title, abstract and keywords;
- language clarity;
- ethics statements;
- conflicts of interest;
- funding information;
- data availability statement;
- artificial intelligence disclosure, when applicable;
- plagiarism, self-plagiarism or textual overlap;
- reference integrity;
- DOI or persistent identifiers in references, when available;
- supplementary files, when applicable;
- compliance with author guidelines.
A submission may be returned to the authors for correction before editorial screening if it does not meet the journal’s technical or formatting requirements.
Technical compliance does not guarantee that the manuscript will be sent for external peer review.
4. Initial Editorial Screening
All manuscripts submitted to JIRRS undergo an initial editorial screening conducted by the Editor-in-Chief, an Associate Editor or a designated handling editor.
At this stage, the editor evaluates whether the manuscript:
- falls within the aims and scope of the journal;
- presents a clear research question, objective or scholarly problem;
- demonstrates originality and relevance;
- uses an appropriate and transparent method;
- meets minimum scientific and methodological standards;
- complies with applicable ethical requirements;
- provides sufficient evidence to support its conclusions;
- presents a potentially relevant contribution to its field;
- follows the journal’s editorial and publication ethics policies.
A manuscript may be declined without external review when it is:
- outside the journal’s scope;
- incomplete;
- insufficiently original;
- methodologically inadequate;
- descriptive without clear scholarly contribution;
- redundant or substantially overlapping with previous publications;
- promotional, commercial or non-scholarly in nature;
- based on unverifiable evidence;
- affected by serious language, structure or formatting problems that prevent proper evaluation;
- affected by plagiarism, citation manipulation, fabricated references or other research integrity concerns;
- lacking required ethical documentation.
Manuscripts that do not meet the minimum editorial, scientific, methodological or ethical requirements may be rejected at this stage before being forwarded for peer review.
5. External Peer Review
Manuscripts considered suitable after editorial screening are normally forwarded to at least two independent reviewers with relevant subject, methodological or interdisciplinary expertise.
Reviewers are selected based on their academic qualifications, research experience, publication record, methodological knowledge and relevance to the manuscript’s field.
Whenever possible, reviewers should not have conflicts of interest involving the authors, institutions, funders, research topic or editorial team.
Reviewers assess, among other aspects:
- originality;
- relevance to the field;
- theoretical or technical foundation;
- clarity of objectives;
- adequacy of study design;
- methodological rigor;
- data quality;
- analytical methods;
- reproducibility;
- ethical compliance;
- transparency of reporting;
- interpretation of findings;
- discussion of limitations;
- adequacy and relevance of citations;
- clarity of writing and organization;
- contribution of the manuscript to knowledge, practice or interdisciplinary debate.
Reviewers must provide objective, respectful, constructive and scientifically reasoned reports.
Reviewer recommendations support the editorial decision, but the final decision remains the responsibility of the editor handling the manuscript.
6. Reviewer Responsibilities
Reviewers invited by JIRRS must:
- accept review assignments only when they have appropriate expertise;
- complete the review within the requested timeframe or inform the editorial office if an extension is needed;
- disclose any potential conflict of interest;
- decline the invitation when impartial evaluation is not possible;
- maintain confidentiality of the manuscript and all related materials;
- avoid using unpublished data, ideas or findings for personal or professional advantage;
- provide clear, evidence-based and constructive comments;
- identify relevant published work that has not been cited, when appropriate;
- report suspected plagiarism, duplicate publication, data fabrication, image manipulation, citation manipulation or other integrity concerns;
- avoid offensive, discriminatory or personal comments.
Reviewers must not share the manuscript with third parties or involve additional reviewers without prior authorization from the editorial office.
Reviewers must not upload unpublished manuscripts, data, figures, tables, supplementary materials or peer-review correspondence to public artificial-intelligence tools or external platforms when doing so may compromise confidentiality.
7. Reviewer Recommendations
After evaluation, reviewers may recommend one of the following decisions:
a) accept;
b) accept subject to minor revisions;
c) major revision followed by further evaluation;
d) reject and invite a new submission;
e) reject.
Reviewer recommendations are advisory. The handling editor may reach a decision that differs from a reviewer’s recommendation when justified by the content of the reports, methodological concerns, ethical considerations, journal policy or the overall quality of the manuscript.
Acceptance is not automatic after revision.
8. Conflicting Reviews
When reviewers provide substantially different recommendations or conflicting assessments, the handling editor may:
- compare the scientific reasoning in each report;
- request clarification from one or more reviewers;
- invite a third independent reviewer;
- seek additional methodological, statistical, technical or ethical assessment;
- consult another editor or member of the editorial board;
- issue a decision based on the evidence and quality of the arguments rather than numerical voting.
A third reviewer may be invited when the disagreement affects the reliability, validity, originality or suitability of the manuscript.
The final decision remains the responsibility of the editor handling the manuscript.
9. Manuscript Revisions
When revisions are requested, authors must submit:
- a revised version of the manuscript;
- a point-by-point response to the reviewers’ and editor’s comments;
- identification of changes made in the manuscript, preferably by page and line number;
- reasoned explanations for comments or suggestions that were not adopted.
Authors must clearly disclose any substantial changes involving:
- data;
- methods;
- analysis;
- results;
- figures or tables;
- authorship;
- ethical approval;
- conflicts of interest;
- funding;
- conclusions.
Depending on the nature and extent of the requested changes, the revised manuscript may be returned to the original reviewers, evaluated by additional specialists or assessed directly by the handling editor.
Failure to respond adequately to reviewers’ and editors’ comments may result in rejection.
Completion of requested revisions does not guarantee acceptance.
10. Editorial Decision
The final editorial decision is the responsibility of the Editor-in-Chief, Associate Editor or handling editor responsible for the manuscript, according to the journal’s editorial workflow.
The decision takes into consideration:
- the reviewers’ reports;
- the scientific quality of the manuscript;
- the methodological rigor of the study;
- originality and relevance;
- ethical compliance;
- adequacy of revisions;
- authors’ responses to review comments;
- suitability for the journal’s aims and scope;
- compliance with JIRRS editorial policies.
Reviewer reports constitute technical and scientific recommendations and support editorial decision-making, but they do not replace the journal’s editorial responsibility.
Editorial decisions are made independently of commercial, financial, institutional or personal interests.
Payment of an Article Processing Charge, waiver status, author nationality, institutional affiliation, professional status or relationship with the publisher does not influence peer review or editorial decisions.
11. Independence and Conflicts of Interest
Editors, reviewers and editorial board members must disclose any potential conflicts of interest involving:
- authors;
- institutions;
- funders;
- research groups;
- commercial entities;
- research topics;
- personal or professional relationships;
- competing academic interests.
When a conflict of interest that may compromise the independence or impartiality of the evaluation is identified, the editor or reviewer involved must withdraw from the process.
In such cases, another independent editor or reviewer will be appointed.
JIRRS seeks to ensure that reviewers do not have relationships or interests that could compromise the impartiality, independence or credibility of the scientific evaluation.
12. Special Issues, Thematic Issues and Supplements
Articles submitted to special issues, thematic issues, supplements or special calls for papers are subject to the same editorial, scientific, ethical and peer review standards applied to articles published in regular issues of JIRRS.
All scholarly manuscripts eligible for scientific evaluation and published in special issues must undergo double-anonymous peer review conducted by at least two independent reviewers.
The participation of guest editors or coordinators of special issues does not reduce or replace the journal’s peer review requirements.
Guest editors may recommend reviewers and support editorial coordination, but final editorial responsibility remains with the journal’s editorial leadership.
When a guest editor, member of the editorial team or member of the editorial board has a conflict of interest involving a particular manuscript, that person must not participate in the evaluation or editorial decision concerning that manuscript.
Special issues must not be used to bypass editorial standards, accelerate acceptance without adequate review or publish content that does not meet the journal’s scientific and ethical requirements.
13. Assignment to Monthly Issues
After final acceptance, a manuscript enters the production workflow, which may include:
- copyediting;
- language adjustments;
- layout editing;
- proofing;
- DOI validation;
- metadata verification;
- author approval of proofs;
- final publication scheduling.
The article is assigned to a monthly issue according to editorial planning and available production capacity.
Acceptance in one month does not guarantee publication in that same month.
JIRRS does not accept payment for priority placement in a monthly issue.
No author, institution or sponsor may purchase accelerated publication, preferential positioning or guaranteed assignment to a specific issue.
14. Expected Timeframes
JIRRS aims to provide:
- initial technical and editorial assessment within approximately ten business days;
- a first decision after external peer review within approximately four to eight weeks;
- a final decision within approximately four to six months, depending on the complexity of the review process.
These are operational targets, not guarantees.
Evaluation may take longer when:
- highly specialized reviewers are required;
- additional methodological or statistical assessment is needed;
- ethics documentation is incomplete;
- reviewers decline invitations or require additional time;
- substantial revisions are requested;
- an integrity concern must be investigated;
- the manuscript addresses an interdisciplinary topic requiring multiple areas of expertise.
Authors may contact the editorial office if no update is received after a reasonable period.
15. Confidentiality
Manuscripts submitted to JIRRS are treated as confidential documents throughout the editorial process.
Editors, reviewers and other participants in the editorial process must not disclose, use or share information, data, results, images, methods or ideas contained in submitted manuscripts before publication, unless expressly authorized by the authors or required for ethical investigation.
Peer review reports, editorial correspondence and decision letters are confidential.
Editors and reviewers must not use unpublished information obtained through peer review for personal, academic, financial or professional advantage.
Unpublished manuscripts, figures, data or confidential correspondence must not be uploaded to public artificial-intelligence systems or external platforms when doing so could compromise editorial confidentiality.
16. Appeals
Authors may appeal an editorial decision when they identify a specific factual, procedural or ethical error in the review or decision-making process.
Disagreement with scientific judgment alone is not sufficient grounds for appeal.
Appeals must:
- clearly identify the manuscript;
- explain the decision being challenged;
- provide a detailed justification;
- indicate the factual, procedural or ethical error alleged;
- include supporting evidence, when available.
Appeals are handled under the journal’s Complaints and Appeals Policy.
When appropriate, an appeal may be reviewed by an editor who was not involved in the original decision.
Submission of an appeal does not guarantee reversal of the editorial decision.
17. Research Integrity Concerns During Peer Review
If plagiarism, data fabrication, image manipulation, citation manipulation, duplicate publication, authorship irregularities, undisclosed conflicts of interest, peer-review manipulation or other integrity concerns are identified during review, the editorial team may pause the evaluation process.
The journal may request explanations, original data, ethics documentation, authorship clarification or other supporting materials.
Depending on the nature and severity of the concern, the manuscript may be rejected, returned for correction, subjected to additional review or referred to the appropriate institutional or ethical authority.
JIRRS may consult relevant publication ethics guidance, including COPE guidance, when handling suspected misconduct.
18. Editorial Integrity
JIRRS keeps its peer review process separate from the journal’s financial, administrative and production decisions.
The purpose of peer review is to ensure the quality, integrity, transparency and reliability of the scholarly record.
The journal does not permit:
- acceptance without appropriate editorial assessment;
- acceptance without peer review for research manuscripts;
- peer review conducted by individuals with unmanaged conflicts of interest;
- manipulation of reviewer identity;
- coercive citation;
- acceptance based on payment;
- priority publication based on payment;
- editorial decisions based on nationality, institutional prestige, personal relationships or commercial considerations.
The journal’s editorial process is guided by independence, transparency, confidentiality, fairness and accountability.
19. Policy Updates
JIRRS may update this Peer Review Policy when necessary to reflect developments in scholarly communication, publication ethics, indexing requirements and editorial best practices.
The version available on the journal website constitutes the current peer review policy of JIRRS.
