Complaints and Appeals

Complaints may concern:

  • editorial procedure;
  • reviewer conduct;
  • conflicts;
  • discrimination;
  • delays;
  • authorship;
  • ethics investigations;
  • corrections;
  • retractions;
  • staff conduct.

Complaints must be sent to:

ethics@jirrs.org.uk

The journal will:

  • acknowledge receipt;
  • request supporting material when necessary;
  • assign the matter to an uninvolved person where possible;
  • document the outcome.

Appeals Against Decisions

An appeal must:

  • be submitted within 30 calendar days;
  • identify a factual, procedural or ethical error;
  • respond to the reasons for rejection;
  • avoid personal accusations;
  • include supporting evidence.

One appeal is normally considered for each manuscript.

The result of the independent appeal review is final within the journal’s internal process.