Plagiarism Policy
1. Commitment to Originality and Research Integrity
The Journal International Review of Research Studies (JIRRS) is committed to originality, transparency, research integrity, and responsible scholarly communication.
All submitted manuscripts must represent original work and must appropriately acknowledge all sources, prior publications, datasets, ideas, methods, figures, tables, and other intellectual contributions used in the manuscript.
JIRRS does not tolerate:
- plagiarism;
- unattributed paraphrasing;
- inappropriate or undisclosed text recycling;
- duplicate or redundant publication;
- simultaneous submission of the same or substantially similar manuscript to more than one journal;
- misappropriation of ideas, data, images, tables, figures, or other scholarly content;
- concealment of closely related prior publications;
- fabricated or misleading references.
2. Routine Similarity Screening
Submitted manuscripts may be screened using text-similarity and plagiarism-detection software as part of the editorial assessment process.
Similarity screening may occur:
- during initial editorial screening;
- before external peer review;
- after revision;
- before final acceptance;
- whenever editors identify a reason for further verification.
The purpose of similarity screening is to support editorial assessment and research-integrity review.
A similarity report does not replace human editorial judgment.
3. Similarity Scores Are Not Automatic Thresholds
JIRRS does not use a single similarity percentage as an automatic threshold for acceptance or rejection.
Editors assess similarity reports by examining:
- the nature of the overlapping material;
- the source of the overlap;
- the location of the overlap within the manuscript;
- whether quotations and citations are appropriate;
- whether methodological terminology is necessarily similar;
- whether the overlap involves previously published work by the same authors;
- whether the overlap affects the originality or scientific contribution of the manuscript.
A low similarity score does not guarantee originality, and a high similarity score does not automatically establish plagiarism.
Editorial decisions are based on the context, extent, relevance, and nature of the overlap.
4. Plagiarism
For the purposes of this policy, plagiarism includes the use of words, ideas, data, findings, images, tables, figures, methods, or other intellectual material created by others without appropriate acknowledgment.
Examples include:
- copying text without appropriate citation;
- closely paraphrasing another source without attribution;
- presenting another person’s ideas or findings as one’s own;
- translating previously published material without identifying the original source;
- reproducing figures, tables, or images without appropriate permission or attribution;
- using unpublished material obtained through peer review, editorial work, or confidential communication without authorization.
5. Text Recycling and Self-Plagiarism
JIRRS recognizes that limited reuse of previously published material may occur in legitimate scholarly contexts, particularly in descriptions of established methods or research procedures.
However, substantial reuse of an author’s previously published text without appropriate disclosure or citation may constitute inappropriate text recycling or self-plagiarism.
Authors must clearly identify and cite relevant previous publications when:
- portions of text have been reused;
- methods have been previously described;
- datasets overlap with earlier studies;
- the manuscript develops or extends previously published findings;
- the submission is derived from a thesis, dissertation, report, preprint, or conference contribution.
The journal evaluates text recycling based on scientific context rather than on similarity percentage alone.
6. Duplicate and Redundant Publication
Manuscripts must not substantially reproduce work already published elsewhere unless a legitimate and transparent editorial justification exists.
Duplicate or redundant publication may include:
- publication of substantially the same article in more than one journal;
- publication of the same dataset and conclusions without appropriate disclosure;
- fragmentation of one study into multiple manuscripts without scientific justification;
- republication in another language without acknowledgment and permission where required.
Authors must disclose any closely related publications or manuscripts during submission.
7. Simultaneous Submission
JIRRS does not accept manuscripts that are simultaneously under consideration by another journal.
By submitting a manuscript, the corresponding author confirms that the work is not under active evaluation elsewhere.
If simultaneous submission is identified, the editorial process may be suspended or terminated.
8. Disclosure of Previous and Related Versions
Authors must disclose any previous or related version of the submitted work, including:
- preprints;
- conference abstracts;
- conference proceedings;
- theses;
- dissertations;
- institutional reports;
- technical reports;
- working papers;
- related manuscripts;
- previous manuscript versions;
- translated publications;
- substantially overlapping datasets or analyses.
Disclosure does not automatically make a manuscript ineligible for publication.
Editors will assess whether the submitted manuscript provides sufficient originality and whether prior dissemination has been transparently acknowledged.
9. Preprints
The existence of a legitimate preprint does not, by itself, constitute prior publication.
Authors must disclose the preprint during submission and provide the relevant persistent identifier or public URL when available.
If the manuscript is accepted, authors should update the preprint record, where possible, to include a citation and DOI link to the final Version of Record.
10. Theses and Dissertations
Manuscripts derived from theses or dissertations may be considered for publication when they represent a scientifically appropriate journal article and the source work is transparently acknowledged.
Authors should disclose the thesis or dissertation during submission and provide the relevant institutional repository information where available.
Reuse of substantial portions of text should be appropriately managed and disclosed.
11. Conference Materials and Reports
Conference abstracts, posters, oral presentations, institutional reports, or preliminary technical documents do not necessarily prevent subsequent journal publication.
However, authors must disclose such materials and ensure that the submitted manuscript provides a substantive scholarly contribution beyond the previously disseminated version.
12. Translated Publications
A translated version of previously published work is not considered an original publication solely because it appears in another language.
A translated or secondary publication may only be considered where:
- the original publication is clearly identified and cited;
- copyright and licensing conditions permit republication;
- any required permission has been documented;
- the authors fully disclose the prior publication;
- a legitimate editorial or scholarly justification exists;
- readers are clearly informed that the work is a translated or secondary publication.
JIRRS will not present a translated republication as an original research article.
When plagiarism is identified, the editorial office may request clarification, require corrections, or reject the manuscript, depending on the severity of the case.
Software Plagiarismo - https://www.turnitin.co.uk/
