Corrections and Retractions

JIRRS corrects the scholarly record when published content is materially inaccurate, unreliable, misleading or affected by misconduct.

Corrections

A correction may be issued when an error affects:

  • interpretation;
  • attribution;
  • metadata;
  • author identification;
  • affiliation;
  • methods;
  • results;
  • integrity;

without invalidating the principal conclusions.

A correction notice will:

  • receive a persistent identifier;
  • identify the article;
  • explain the change;
  • identify who requested the correction;
  • link to and from the original article.

Expressions of Concern

An expression of concern may be issued when:

  • serious doubts exist;
  • an investigation remains incomplete;
  • an institution does not respond;
  • evidence is inconclusive;
  • legal or procedural restrictions delay a final decision.

Retractions

An article may be retracted when:

  • findings are unreliable;
  • data were fabricated or falsified;
  • plagiarism occurred;
  • redundant publication occurred;
  • research was unethical;
  • authorship was manipulated;
  • peer review was manipulated;
  • major error invalidates the conclusions.

Retraction notices will:

  • remain freely accessible;
  • identify the article;
  • explain the reason;
  • distinguish error from misconduct where possible;
  • identify who requested the retraction;
  • link bidirectionally to the article.

Retracted articles normally remain accessible with a clear retraction label.

Removal is reserved for exceptional legal, privacy or safety circumstances.